Choose one journal article to read and critique (you may need to do several readings to fully understand it). Note the rationale for the study, its purpose, the basic method used, the results, and the discussion of the results. Unless you’ve had advanced statistical courses, the results section may be difficult to understand, but try to understand as much as you can. Notice that the article’s abstract and the discussion section often emphasize the major findings. Answer these questions about the study:
What was the purpose of the study?
How was the study conducted? (Who were the subjects? What did the subjects do?)
What was found in the study?
What are the limitations of the study?
Did the author(s) acknowledge the limitations of the study?
Did the results and discussion seem consistent? Explain.
What implications do the study’s findings have for us?
If you were conducting research in this area, what would be the next study you would conduct based on the outcome of this study? That is, where do we go from here?
Remember the following about doing a critique of this study:
I have already read the article, so don’t spend as much time summarizing the article as you do critiquing it.
In your critique, don’t just focus on the negative aspects of the study. Rather, try to present a balanced view of the study’s strengths and limitations.
Refer to How to write a critique handout
this is the study I’d like you to critique: http://sportspa.ftos.untz.ba/images/june2023/rad%202%20jun%202023%20edited.pdf
that should be all, I am at work from 11am-7pm pst tmrw so I might not be able to answer questions